The Grillin’ Fools families journey annually to Michigan for vacation.  A very important part of the vacation involves chasing salmon around the cold, deep waters of Lake Michigan and of course grilling that wonderful fish.  One year Grillin’ Fool Tom and crew hijacked (not really) a charter boat to learn what goes on in salmon-nation before embarking out to the deep in their own dingy.  This is a chronicle of the day on the charter as well as pretty cool trick for grilling salmon using a brown paper bag. Scroll down for Brown Bag Salmon. 

Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   40
Brown Bag Salmon on the Grill  GrillinFools Images ©

The day began early with 10-mile ride to an area determined by the ship’s captain to be a prime location for some big salmon.

Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   01
A salmon already on the line  GrillinFools Images ©

Fish on at dawn!!

Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   02
The first fish sighting  GrillinFools Images ©

Scott George (not Grillin’ Fool Scott but a friend) must have a big one on the line.  A 45 minute battle has begun.  Who will win?  Fish or man?

Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   03
Landing the first fish  GrillinFools Images ©

Grillin’ Fool Tom readies the net!

Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   04
Get the net  GrillinFools Images ©
Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   07
Nuttin but net  GrillinFools Images ©

Friend Brian casually observes Captain Frank securing our meal.

Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   08
Nice fish  GrillinFools Images ©

Scott George with his prize:

Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   10
Fine Prize  GrillinFools Images ©

Tom scours the water for another salmon for the grill.

Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   12
Scanning for fish or saluting  GrillinFools Images ©

Captain Frank comes to the aid of Tom, aka Big Green Eggspert, who has a scrappy one on the line.

Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   Collage 01
WOW  GrillinFools Images ©

Scott George, Tom, and Brad having a smooth return ride.

Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   17
Does it get any better than friends and fishing  GrillinFools Images ©

When Tom returned he was showing Greg all the photos taken on the cruise and he was especially proud of his composition of this one with the lighthouse in the background…guess he earned his stripes.

Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   18
Shadow stripes  GrillinFools Images ©

Here’s the motley crew with the catch of the day.

Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   21
What a catch  GrillinFools Images ©

With the 3-chord progression played by The Troggs ringing in our ears Captain Frank prepares to clean the catch or is there something crazy about him?

Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   19
You make my heart sing  GrillinFools Images ©

Grillin’ Fool Tom filets a salmon for the grill then slices another into chunks.

Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   Collage 02
FRESH  GrillinFools Images ©

Now it is time to head back to the cabins, grab a cold one, and stoke up the dueling travel charcoal grills:

Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   Collage 03
Grill on  GrillinFools Images ©

Captains Frank and Elaine Pierce, yes they’re both licensed U.S. Coast Guard Captains, showed Grillin’ Fools Tom and Greg a new way to brown bag it… on the grill:

Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   29
Captain Captain  GrillinFools Images ©

Place a skin-on, soon to be grilled salmon, filet on a paper grocery sack, skin side down, then trim around the filet leaving a border of a half inch or what we call brown bag salmon.

Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   Collage 04
The magic of brown bag salmon  GrillinFools Images ©

Simple treatment for the brown bag salmon, massage olive oil into the meat side of the salmon, dust with your favorite seasoning, we used a Jamaican seasoning on half and a commercial bbq rub on the other half:

Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   Collage 05
Oil and season  GrillinFools Images ©

Fish on!!!  The grill that is!  We’re grilling the brown bag salmon over direct heat. Will the brown bag burst into flames before we get some tasty grilled salmon??

Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   41
On the brown bag and on the grill  GrillinFools Images ©

Here’s a close-up of the skin curling and the juice from grilled salmon combining with the oil and beginning to bubble. It’s getting close to dinnertime now.

Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   42
No risk of the bag burning  GrillinFools Images ©

Here’s another close-up showing the pin bones that can/should be removed prior to grilling.

Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   43
Make sure to take these out before eating  GrillinFools Images ©

The grilled salmon is ready after 8-10 minutes on the grill, depending on the size of the salmon.  This was a small fish but it was grilled till flaky and it was indeed tasty.

Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   44
Ready to remove the brown bag and serve  GrillinFools Images ©

The reason for this grilling method is to provide an easy, foolproof way to remove the skin after grilling while maintaining high moisture content in the salmon.  The grilled salmon was picked up by the tail, laid bag side up, then the brown bag simply peeled away with a juicy salmon filet remaining.

Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   Collage 06
Peal the bag  GrillinFools Images ©

Here’s the nasty skin stuck to the brown bag.

Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   49
Thats the magic  GrillinFools Images ©

Cool, huh?

Brown Bag Salmon From Hook to Cook   28
Grillin Fool Tom says youll catch em this big  GrillinFools Images ©

The following year, Grillin’ Fool Scott went out on the Wild Thing II and caught this beauty:

Scott with his prize Salmon
Scott with his Prize Salmon  GrillinFools Images ©

And in 2021, my oldest son went on his first excursion out on Lake Michigan and pulled in this beast:

Not bad for his first time  GrillinFools Images ©

The catch of the day in 2021 was this 40 inch MONSTER:

Blake pulled in that behemoth  GrillinFools Images ©

You can read more about that fishing trip as well as the Cherry Plank Salmon or Whiskey Maple Syrup Salmon we did by clicking the link.

If you have any questions or comments, feel free to leave them below or send me an email.

Also, you can follow us on our GrillinFools Facebook pageInstagram, and YouTube feeds

GrillinFools Images ©
author avatar
GrillinFools Images ©
Tom Jones

This article was initially published on:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *