Blueberry Muffin Fatty. What is a fatty? Not what you might think. Simply put, a fatty, or sausage fatty, is bulk sausage, stuffed or otherwise, formed into a loaf and smoked. They can be savory: stuffed with cheese and roasted corn. They can be sweet: filled with minced apples and vidalia onions. This one is along the lines of the latter and is another in a long list of Arthur Aguirre’s great recipes…

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 23

***Editor’s Note ~ Arthur has started his own blog and I’m more than happy to promote him on mine.  His new site is called***

Almost a year after I debuted as the first guest Grillin Fool, on April 2nd this partnership was taken to another level. Scott “The Original GrillinFool” asked me to assist with a Hot Shot’s event in downtown St. Louis on opening weekend for the Cardinal baseball season. I’ve never done an event like this, but before I had time to process his invitation, he gave me the rundown of the planned event:

  1. Grill and serve BBQ to Hot Shots guests
  2. Sample some new local brew
  3. Hang out with the Hot Shot girls
  4. See Woody from 105.7 The Point
  5. Schmooze with Cardinal fans

How could I say no? Before I agreed, I had already blacked out that date from my calendar and immediately started brainstorming ideas for the BBQ. Then I told Scott calmly, ‘Cool, I’m in”, while in my head I was doing cartwheels.

I volunteered to make 4 fatties, because they are easy to prepare and always a crowd pleaser. However, in true Grillin Fool fashion, I wanted to kick it up a notch. I ignored making any sausage fatty that has been done on this site, including the local sensation, Slinger Fatty. Instead, I have seen that some folks were making fatties stuffed with pancakes. I knew instantly that this is something I had to do for the event.

Blueberry Muffin Fatty Ingredients

  • 1 – 7 oz box Jiffy blueberry muffin mix
  • 1 – 16 oz roll of Jimmy Dean regular pork sausage
  • maple syrup

-Makes (1) fatty
-Total prep and cook time: 2hr 30min to 3hrs

Blueberry Muffin Fatty

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 2

The fatty was prepared 2 different ways: 1) using a fatty piston. 2) Rolling by hand. We’ll start with the fatty piston method first.

The fatty piston is a device that is made out of PVC pipe materials. It’s cut to length and comes with a push rod, hence, using it like a piston.

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 3

1. Bake muffin mix according to directions on the box. Let it cool down.

This much took an hour to bake for (4) fatties.

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 4

Just reach in and set some aside.

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 5

2. Prepare the muffin stuffing.
a. Hold the PVC pipe upright on top of a sheet of plastic wrap (large enough to wrap the pipe)

b. Start stuffing small chunks of blueberry muffin into the pipe while intermittently adding syrup between chunks.

c. Use the push rod to compact the muffin and syrup.

d. When the pipe is full, wrap the plastic wrap around it

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 6

e. Place the stuffed pipe in the freezer for at least 30 minutes.

Here is the blueberry stuffing after sitting in the freezer and pushed out of the pipe. As you can see, the frozen syrup is holding everything together.

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 6

3. Flatten the sausage to a ¼ inch thickness.


Blueberry Muffin Fatty 7


Blueberry Muffin Fatty 8

4. Place the muffin on top of the sausage and roll it into a shape of a tube.

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 8

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 9

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 10

5. These blueberry muffin stuffed fatties were smoked at the Hot Shots event and as a result, I didn’t take any good pictures of the final product due to all the work and a little revelry. However, I do know we cooked them on the grill with indirect heat at 300 degrees for 2 hours with apricot wood. In addition, a generous coating of Scott’s pumpkin spice rub was applied too.  You can use your own favorite rub for this.

Here they are right after we put them on the grill with some baloney bites.

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 11

Here are the blueberry muffin stuffed fatties almost done.

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 12

I’m in the zone.

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 13

Since many folks don’t have a fatty piston, here are directions for doing it by hand:

Blueberry Muffin Fatty Instructions:

1. Same as Step 1 above.

2. Same as Step 3 above.

3. Place chunks of muffin (approx. 2 cups) on top of the sausage.

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 14

4. Drizzle the syrup over the muffin chunks.

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 15

5. Roll the sausage into a shape of a tube. This is a bit harder without the fatty piston.

First, fold it over.

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 16

Second, overlap the ends and smooth the seams by massaging the sausage and eliminating any cracks or crevices as the fatty will split at any of them. Make sure to distribute the sausage evenly so it cooks evenly.

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 17

6. I made a sweet rub to coat the outside of the fatty.

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 18

7. My grill was prepared for an indirect heat setup on the Grill Manufacturer That Shall Not Be Named. I used only about 1/3 chimney of charcoal.

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 19

Next, I dumped the hot coals in the kettle banked to one side. I added a few fresh briquettes and a couple chunks of peach wood.

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 20

After that, the blueberry muffin stuffed fatty is placed on the grill grate opposite from the heat.

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 21

Put the lid on with the vents over the top of the fatty, opposite from the heat. This is so the smoke travels over sausage and out the vents. Also, I initially had the vents wide open…I think closing them halfway is what I should have done.

When 30 minutes passed, the temp had reached close to 400 degrees (always keep an eye out for runaway temps, no charcoal grill is a “set it and forget it” cooker.)

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 22

I closed the top vents halfway and the temps eventually dropped to 325.

An hour passed and the blueberry muffin stuffed fatty is done thanks to the early blast of heat.

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 23

The sausage fatty rests in a foil tent for 15 minutes or until it cools down enough to handle.

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 24

And finally, the money shot…

Blueberry Muffin Fatty Close up.

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 25

My thoughts: The fatty piston is the easy way to make fatties, however, the trade off is more steps and more time involved. Another positive is that the fatty doesn’t lose its round shape, as a result, it makes for great presentation. Without the fatty piston, it flattens a bit into an oval shape. Obviously, there is no difference in taste, they were both delicioso!

Blueberry Muffin Fatty Notes:

1. Using plastic wrap on the prep area works best for making fatties.
2. Make sure to massage your sausage to cover up any creases or crevasses so the fatty doesn’t split open.
3. The longer the sausage sits at room temp, the harder it is to work with.
4. Firm it up by partially freezing the fatty before smoking it.
5. Use fruit wood such as apple, cherry, apricot or peach for smoke.

Lot’s of folks raved about the blueberry muffin stuffed fatty at Hot Shots. There was even a guy that heard Woody on the radio mention the “blueberry muffin wrapped in sausage” and he stopped by the party to try it…unfortunately, “we ran out”, I told him. Instead, I hooked him up with a KC Sweet and Smokey rib and baloney bites.

I’m sure glad everybody at Hot Shots liked the sausage fatty because I told Scott that I taste tested it before the event…I lied.

***Editor’s Note ~ I’m sure glad too.  Sure glad we didn’t find out the hard way they sucked, being in front of a crowd of people.  But they were fantastic, and I don’t like blueberries, if that is any indication of how good they were***

A shot for me and the crew after the event was over and we had everything loaded up.

Blueberry Muffin Fatty 26

If you have any questions or comments, feel free to leave them below or shoot them to Scott in an email to send to me.

If you liked the blueberry muffin stuffed fatty recipe and are interested in other fatty recipes, click here.

Also, you can follow us on our GrillinFools Facebook pageInstagram, and YouTube feeds

Print Recipe
5 from 1 vote

Blueberry Muffin Fatty

Bulk sausage, stuffed with blueberry muffins and syrup and smoked on the grill
Prep Time30 minutes
Cook Time2 hours
Total Time2 hours 30 minutes
Course: Appetizer
Cuisine: BBQ
Servings: 6 -8


  • 1 9" x 13" pan


  • 7 oz Jiffy blueberry muffin mix
  • 16 oz Jimmy Dean regular pork sausage
  • maple syrup
  • your favorite sweet rub


  • Prepare the blueberry muffins in a 9"X13" pan according to the instructions on the box (Makes enough for four fatties)
  • Spread out a sheet of plastic wrap on the counter and spread the sausage out to 1/4 inch thickness
  • Place 1/4 of the blueberry muffins in the middle of the flattened sausage
  • Drizzle maple syrup over the muffins.
  • Grab the plastic wrap and roll the fatty into a loaf
  • Wrap the plastic wrap tight around the sausage fatty and go out to the grill
  • Prepare the grill for two zone/indirect grilling with coals and smoke wood on one side and nothing on the other
  • Target temperature of the grill is 300-325
  • The sausage fatty should be grilled for about two hours depending on the heat of the grill
  • Remove from the grill, allow to rest for 8-10 minutes, slice and serve


Arthur Aguirre

Arthur Aguirre

Major League Grilling’s founder, Arthur Aguirre, is a BBQ enthusiast with a passion to cook anything on the grill. Before reaching the level of pitmaster, Arthur spent years of hopelessly under cooking and overcooking various cuts of succulent meats. With the help of internet forums such as the BBQ Brethren, Char-Broil, and the experts from the Grillin' Fools, Arthur’s grilling exploits soon followed.
Arthur Aguirre
Arthur Aguirre
Arthur Aguirre

Latest posts by Arthur Aguirre (see all)


Frickin Fantabulous Fatty. Followed your step by steps and the results were just short of a miracle. Didn’t have enough time to order the piston but made my own and it worked great. I used one package of Tennessee Pride Mild and 1 package of Bob Evans, both were remarkable. The whole family loved it and my only regret was only making 2.


Thanks for the review Chad….fatty’s are easy and an instant crowd pleaser! Keep’em coming!


Tried this recipe yesterday. Didn’t have a piston, and I think my filling roll was too big, which caused a seam to open up while cooking, but it all held together and got raves from our guests.

Going to buy a piston and try again. Thanks for the post!


@Nick, it takes practice to close up those seams and crevasses good. It happens to me all the time. I’ve tried at least 3 different ways to make a fatty. The piston is a handy tool, I hope you like it too.

Glad to hear you got some props from your guests, it feels good, don’t it? You’re just getting warmed up…keep’em coming!


Just tried the fatties for the first time and they were lived up to all the hype. The kids ate it like it was candy



The Fatty Piston maker seems to no longer be making the pistons. Put my order in and no word for almost a month. No response to email as well. Hope all is well with the guy.

I am eager to make my first Fatty…could you give me the tube length & circumference? I’ll need to make one on my own!



Oh, that sucks. Those things rock! Seems like there is a market out there for these things. Wish I had time to make them…

Thanks for your post. I was trying to gauge the feasibility of a cranberry stuffing fatty, and it looks like blueberry muffin would be the same consistency. I’m planning dried cranberries in cornbread stuffing, and a glaze of cranberry bbq sauce.



That sounds fantastic!


5 stars
This was a great recipe, that I made for a few neighbors as a brunch treat.
Everyone loved it. I did utilize my own 2” pvc pipe that I cut off at twelve inches and used an empty spice jar to tamp down my muffin and syrup mixture.
I also decided to add a basket wave of bacon on the outside, because, why not? Am I right?
Thank you for this wonderful recipe, I will be using it again during the holidays!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating