If there were a Mount Rushmore of Sandwiches, the Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich would definitely be on the short list of finalists of that lofty honor. Hamburger, grilled cheese, po’ boy, lobster roll, hot dog (yeah, it’s a sammich, prove me wrong), pastrami on rye, French dip, sub sando, and a few others would be in the discussion. For me, it would be the hamburger (this cheeseburger to be specific), grilled cheese, lobster roll and the Philly for my top four, not necessarily in that order. With this recipe, we are going to make the Grilled Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich a few different ways. I encourage you to try some different options to find your favorite.

Grilled Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich Ingredients

Per sandwich:

1/4 cup chopped onion
1/4 cup chopped bell peppers (optional)
Olive oil
1/2 lb shaved beef
Your favorite beef or steak rub
Salt and pepper
2 slices of provolone cheese
1 hoagie bun
Spray oil

Don’t forget the Reynolds Wrap® Non-Stick Foil

Ingredients for Philly Cheese Steak Sandwiches

Let’s start with the most basic of the Philly. Chop those onions:

Slicing onions Slicing onions

Then set up the grill for two zone grilling with coals on one side and nothing on the other. Then tear off a long sheet of Reynolds Wrap® Non-Stick Foil:

Time for the aluminum foil

Place one end of the foil over the hot side of the grill and drizzle some olive oil. Make sure the dull side of the foil is facing up. That’s the non-stick side:

Oiling up the aluminum foil

The oil isn’t really to keep the ingredients from sticking. Reynolds Wrap® Non-Stick Foil will take care of that. It’s to help transfer the heat to the ingredients. See, foil is outstanding at dissipating heat. The oil here will help cook the food faster, and at the same time, keep it from burning. 

Wait for the oil to get close to 300F:

Oil reading 285F

Next, drop the onions for however many sandos you plan on cooking on the end of the foil over the hot coals:

Cooking onions on aluminum foil on the grlll

Season the onions with salt and pepper:

seasoning the onions

Once the onions soften a bit and get a little color on them, grab a couple plastic turners and flip the onions over:

flipping the onions

A little browning is a good thing:

Browned and softened onions

Then add the meat:

Adding 1/2 pound of shaved beef

I know that a 1/2 pound sounds like a lot for some, but after it cooks, it will not be a 1/2 pound. It will lose some water weight. 

Pick your favorite steak or beef seasoning:

seasoning

Season that beef with as much salt, pepper and seasoning as you like:

Seasoning the beef

After some browning on the bottom of that beef, grab those plastic turners again and flip everything over, working the onions into the meat:

Working the onions into the beef

Then form the meat and onions roughly into the shape of a bun. It’s OK if the meat is larger than the footprint of the bun. In fact, that is encouraged:

Shaping the cooked onions and beef

Then top with a couple slices of cheese:

Adding cheese to the cooked beef and onions

Next, slide the foil to the side of the grill with no heat and fold the Reynolds Wrap® Non-Stick Foil over the meat, onions and cheese and form a pouch:

Creating a foil pouch Creating a foil pouch A foil pouch to melt the cheese

Set that on the side with no heat and let the cheese melt. While the cheese is melting, let’s prep our buns. One way of preparing the buns is to toast them. Who doesn’t love some toasty buns, #AmIRight? Start by coating them with some oil spray on the sliced side:

Spraying the buns with oil

Then set the oiled hoagie buns over the coals but don’t go far. Don’t go to the bathroom. Don’t grab an adult beverage. Also, keep peeking every 30-60 seconds:

Toasting the buns

Once some grill marks form, rotate 45 degrees, and THAT is how we make beautiful, cross-hatched buns:

Cross hatched buns

Our cheese should be melted by now so get the foil ready and let’s plate this bad boy:

Melted cheese

Set one of the buns on top of that pile of cheesy, savory deliciousness:

Assembling the Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich

Then lift the foil on one side and lean the meat, onion and cheese onto the bun:

Assembling the Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich Assembling the Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich

BOOM!

Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich

Now we will make my preferred method of a Grilled Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich. The traditionalists will be all up in arms about this one. Start off by chopping some sweet bell peppers. There are four main kinds of sweet bells which are all just various stages of ripeness of one bell. Green, yellow, orange and red. Only the latter three are acceptable. Green bell peppers are simply not ripe:

Chopping peppers Chopped peppers and onions

Now, lay down that Reynolds Wrap® Non-Stick Foil again, dull side facing up, and drizzle the oil. Once the oil gets up to temp lay down the peppers first and let them sizzle for a couple minutes then drop the onions:

Adding the onions to the peppers on the foil

Season the peppers and onions with salt and pepper. Wait for the peppers and onions to brown a bit on the bottom and get the plastic turners out:

Mixing up the onions and peppers Browned peppers and onions

Once both the peppers and onions are soft and have some color, drop that meat:

Adding shaved beef to the peppers and onions

And then hit the meat with some seasoning:

Seasoning the beef

Once the meat has browned somewhat, flip everything over, making sure to mix the peppers and onions in with the steak:

Mixing the peppers and onions into the shaved beef

And once the meat browns a little more, form the meat/peppers/onions into a bun shape and lay down a couple slices of cheese on each pile:

Adding the provelone

It’s OK if the meat is a little pink when you top with the cheese. When we close up the foil, the meat will cook the rest of the way. So slide the foil over to the side with no heat and close the foil over the meat/peppers/onions/cheese:

Forming an aluminum foil pouch Forming an aluminum foil pouch An aluminum foil pouch

It won’t take long for the cheese to melt. In just a couple minutes, we can repeat the process of assembling the sandwiches:

Assembling the Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich assembling the Philly Cheese Steak Sandwiches

And look at that. Despite all that ooey, gooey, melty cheese, we don’t have any stuck to the foil thanks to the Reynolds Wrap® Non-Stick Foil:

No cheese stuck to the foil

But let’s proceed to our final step, which is simply to take one of those sandwiches and wrap it in foil:

Wrapping a Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich in foil Wrapping a Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich in foil Wrapping a Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich in foil A Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich wrapped in foil

The heat from the meat/peppers/onions/cheese will steam the buns and make them warm and soft.

And after all that, pick your options:

  • Just onions
  • Peppers and onions
  • Toasted bun
  • Warm and soft bun
  • Toasted bun that is then steamed inside the foil

And of course, all the combinations of the above you can think of:

Philly Cheese Steak Sandwiches

Almost forgot the greenery:

Philly Cheese Steak Sandwiches

What can I say about this iconic sando? Savory steak, soft onions (and optional peppers), melty cheese, and either a toasted bun or a warm/soft bun (or both). I could eat one of these every day. And they are really simple to make. It will take longer to grab the ingredients than it will to cook and assemble a Grilled Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich. 

This post was brought to you by the fine folks from Reynolds Wrap® whom I’ve been working with since 2015. I’m honored and humbled to have partnered with such a revered brand for that long. Not only that, their products are vital to the backyard and competition cookers alike. I can’t imagine how much Reynolds Wrap® Foil and aluminum pans I go through in a year.

If you have any questions, feel free to leave them below or shoot me an email

Grilled Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich
Author: 
Recipe type: Sandwich
Cuisine: Street Food
Prep time: 
Cook time: 
Total time: 
Serves: 4-6
 
Shaved beef, seasoned and mixed with grilled onions (and optional peppers), before being topped with cheese and made into a Grilled Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich
Ingredients
  • ¼ cup chopped onion
  • ¼ cup chopped bell peppers (optional)
  • Olive oil
  • ½ lb shaved beef
  • Your favorite beef or steak rub
  • Salt and pepper
  • 2 slices of provelone cheese
  • 1 hoagie bun
  • Spray oil
  • Reynolds Wrap® Non-Stick Foil
Instructions
  1. Chop the onions
  2. Chop the peppers (optional)
  3. Prepare the grill for two zone grilling, with coals on one side and nothing on the other
  4. Place a long sheet of Reynolds Wrap® Non-Stick Foil on the grill, dull side up (that's the non-stick side), with half of it over the coals
  5. Drizzle a tablespoon of olive oil on the foil
  6. Add the onions and optional peppers once the oil reads close to 300F
  7. Season peppers and onions with salt and pepper
  8. Brown up the peppers and onions until slightly browned and soft
  9. Add the shaved beef and season with steak or beef rub
  10. Once the meat has browned, flip over to brown the other side
  11. After most of the meat is browned, form the meat/peppers/onions into a bun shape and top with two slices of cheese
  12. Slide the foil over to the side with no heat and fold the foil over and pinch off to form a pouch
  13. While the cheese melts, toast the buns by spraying the buns with oil
  14. Place the buns over the hot side of the grill to toast
  15. Once grill marks appear, rotate the buns 45 degrees
  16. Once they are cross hatched, remove from heat
  17. Open the foil pouch and slide the meat/peppers/onions/cheese onto the bun and serve
  18. Optional, wrap the assembled Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich in foil and place over the heat for a couple minutes to steam the bun
  19. Serve
 

Scott Thomas

Scott Thomas

Scott Thomas, the Original Grillin’ Fool, was sent off to college with a suitcase and a grill where he overcooked, undercooked and burned every piece of meat he could find. After thousands of failures, and quite a few successes, nearly two decades later he started a website to show step by step, picture by picture, foolproof instructions on how to make great things out of doors so that others don’t have to repeat the mistakes he’s made on the grill.
Scott Thomas

@GrillinFool

https://t.co/lVWgniik3V - #GrillPorn abounds here. All meat, all the time!
Oh my wow! There is so much perfection right there! 😲✔️👍😎 . Video shot by the insanely talented @carlaocarvalho77 …… https://t.co/uKHWyunSxp - 4 years ago
Scott Thomas

Latest posts by Scott Thomas (see all)

2 comments

Hello!
Looks scrumptious and I cannot wait to try! What steak seasoning/rubs do you recommend? Our favorite (HardCore Canivorne) I can’t picture being right for this? Thank you!

Reply

Elizabeth,

I have a Hardcore Carnivore decal on my car! Big fan. I listed the rub I used in this article (DB180):

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rate this recipe: