Chuck Eye Steak1 What is a chuck eye steak? It is often referred to as the poor man’s rib eye and that is for good reason. Rib eyes are cut from the 6th to the 12th rib of the cow. The chuck eye is cut off the 5th rib. Don’t confuse them with chuck steaks. These are chuck EYE steaks. There are only two chuck eye steaks per cow so they aren’t always available. But when they are, they are quite the treat at a much discounted rate from the lauded rib eye:

Chuck Eye Steak - 003
That’s an 11.2 ounce steak for under six bucks!

The chuck eye does not quite have the flavor of the rib eye, particularly the money muscle around the top, outer edge, and isn’t quite as tender, but it is darn close. And for the price difference, it’s well worth the slight downgrade. To compensate for it not quite being a rib eye, I don’t recommend taking the chuck eye steak beyond medium. It also marries well with a marinade prior to grilling or basting during. I always keep my steaks below medium, and opted for the basting with some Andria’s Steak Sauce while I grilled it.

Ingredients:

2 chuck eye steaks
Salt
Black pepper
White pepper
Andria’s Steak Sauce, reserved for later

No amounts here. I kept it uber simple with this one.

The chuck eye steaks out of their cellophane prison:

Chuck Eye Steak - 010
That’s some good looking meat!

Time to season before we prep the grill:

Chuck Eye Steak - 020
Ready to Season

Hit it with salt, black and white pepper:

Chuck Eye Steak - 022 Chuck Eye Steak - 023

Prepare the grill for high heat, two zone grilling with coals or burners blaring hot on one side and nothing on the other side. In this case, I used the upper rack of my Char-Broil TRU Infrared as the second zone.

Before we go any further, if your grill doesn’t get lava hot anymore, then your steak is going to get roasted rather than seared. Those grill marks are going to be more like grill shadows of what your grill used to be. Before you junk the grill and buy a new one, a lot of the times there is a simple fix. A faulty fuel regulator is MUCH cheaper to replace than the entire grill and surprisingly simple to replace. Let the fine folks at GrillPartsSearch.com help you out getting that grill back into shape.

Place the steak on the hot side of the grill and rotate after 3-4 minutes 45 degrees to get those perfect grill marks:

Chuck Eye Steak - 033 Chuck Eye Steak - 034

After another 3-4 minutes flip over and repeat on the other side:

Chuck Eye Steak - 041
Can you say Grill Marks?

Don’t forget the basting of Andria’s Steak Sauce after the sear and the first flip:

Chuck Eye Steak - 047
Mmmm, basted goodness!

After it is seared, rotated and seared again on the other side (and grill marks achieved on both sides), flip over and transfer to the cool zone, in this case the top rack of my Char-Broil TRU Infrared:

Chuck Eye Steak - 057
I’m hungry just looking at that!

Another layer of sultry, savory deliciousness from Andria’s:

Chuck Eye Steak - 065
Awesomesauce!

Don’t forget the other steak. The one above was for my Father in Law who likes his steaks medium. The one below is mine, with more great grill marks, which I cooked a bit short of medium:

Chuck Eye Steak - 078 Chuck Eye Steak - 083 Chuck Eye Steak - 086

How much short of medium did I go with mine? You tell me:

Chuck Eye Steak2

And a bonus shot of that wonderful redness!

Chuck Eye Steak - 114
Outstanding!

This steak was outstanding. It was highly equivalent to the man part of the rib eye (not the outer money muscle of the much more expensive rib eye), at a much reduced cost. It was tender, juicy and with the added Andria’s, had a ton of flavor. I will be on the look out for these in the future. I plan on stocking my freezer with them. At that price, they are the perfect steak to stock up on particularly with beef prices on the rise.

If you have any questions about what is a chuck eye steak or how to grill them, feel free to leave them below or shoot me an email.

If you liked this grilling recipe and would like others with beef, and more wonderful grill marks, click here.

Also, you can follow the Grillin Fools on their Facebook page where you can post your own grilling pictures, share grilling recipes, or join the general grilling conversation.  You can also follow them on Twitter @GrillinFool

4.0 from 1 reviews
What is a Chuck Eye Steak?
Author: 
Recipe type: Entree
Cuisine: Steak
Prep time: 
Cook time: 
Total time: 
Serves: 2
 
Definition of what a chuck eye steaks are and how to simply grill them
Ingredients
  • 2 chuck eye steaks
  • Salt
  • Black pepper
  • White pepper
  • Andria’s Steak Sauce, reserved for later
Instructions
  1. Coat the steaks with with salt, black and white pepper then prepare the grill
  2. Set the grill for high heat, two zone grilling - blaring hot on one side and cool on the other
  3. Place the steaks on the hot side of the grill, sear for 3-4 minutes, rotate 45 degrees and sear for another 3-4 minutes to get great grill marks
  4. Flip over and repeat the searing process after slathering with Andria's Steak Sauce.
  5. Once the other side is seared, moved to the side with no heat, slather with Andria's and close the lid to bake until the desired doneness.
  6. Bake for 4 minutes to get to medium rare and 8 minutes for medium. Do not cook beyond medium
Scott Thomas

Scott Thomas

Scott Thomas, the Original Grillin’ Fool, was sent off to college with a suitcase and a grill where he overcooked, undercooked and burned every piece of meat he could find. After thousands of failures, and quite a few successes, nearly two decades later he started a website to show step by step, picture by picture, foolproof instructions on how to make great things out of doors so that others don’t have to repeat the mistakes he’s made on the grill.
Scott Thomas

@GrillinFool

http://t.co/FxaUMvg9r4 - Dedicated to step by step, picture by picture, foolproof grillin' instructions.
Fire + Meat = Happy Me! #Repost from @strassburgersteaks ・・・ Do you love to play with fir… http://t.co/OlCtSopJ13 http://t.co/u2xgQjdBXz - 38 mins ago
Scott Thomas

Latest posts by Scott Thomas (see all)

21 comments

It is rare that I see chuck eye steaks at our stores but the next time I will give them a try, yours looks great.

Reply

Chris,

I rarely see them either, but when I do I grab all I can which is usually two!

…….Scott

Just got back from Walmart Neighborhood Market, I saw one 2 pack @ $6.79 lb.
never heard of the cut before so I left without it and came home to research it and found this site.
I’ve got my meat guy on speed dial at “Nugget Market”. He said they had five and is putting aside two for
me, but they don’t always have it.
I then asked him if he could order some in the future on a days notice?
He said what he would do for me is

Bob,

Sounds like you got the hook up! I haven’t had chuck eye since I did that post and that’s a crying shame!

…….Scott

Great looking steaks! Thanks for sharing this, I’d not seen the cut before and will definitely be in the lookout for them

Reply

I live in SE Michigan – my local meijer often has CAB chuckeye roasts and steaks for under $4/lb. For my money its some of the best meat locally available (aside from more expensive cuts and down in eastern market)

I feel like a thief every time my local grocery store has this on sale. It’s normally $6.49/lb (already a deal for how good it is) but just a few days ago had it on sale for $3.49/lb. Yes, please! I took all five packages.

I tried this cut of steak on a whim a couple years ago and fell in love with it. It’s harder to find than most. I’ve noticed that when my local grocer does a huge deal (BOGO, 50% off) on their chuck roasts then that’s when they have a ton of chuck-eye steaks and I snatch up as much as I can.

Reply

Furlonium,

Excellent tip on when to find these as I rarely find them myself…

…….Scott

I found this page from Google because I have to know how to cook
beef(from chuck part) which on grilled, while I am searching key word
“chuck eye”.
This part of beef, Chuck eye is more cheaper than
others. High oil and hard meat if cooked over, so I prefer what you said
: Beyond medium!!! Thanks.
BUT reeking of meat if too rare…><

Reply

Stop telling the world about my secret steak!! Its all I buy. Unfortunately the prices have risen over the last year

Reply

I know, I feel the same way. When I ask the butcher to cut me some (if that’s an option) I lower my voice to barely-audible so no-one else will hear me 😀

My son in law was a meat cutter for a major grocer in the area, he turned me onto chuck eye steaks ten yrs ago, and I’ll never go back, the problem is, that the meat cutters have first pick! LOL

Reply

KW, yes they do! I rarely find them, but when I do, I buy all of them I can…

…….Scott

OMG, I love the chuck eye. I, too, buy up all the pkgs when I see them. Turned my son onto them and he turned me on to this site. Your steak looks delicious, I wanted to lick the screen. I discovered them 2 years ago and yes, the prices have risen to $6 per lb. but I wait for a sale of under $5 and stock the freezer. Thanks for the article.

Reply

Eva,

Glad to here there are other Chuck Eye enthusiasts out there. What is your favorite way to grill them?

…….Scott

Scott, many times I pan sear in a cast iron pan with steak seasoning. I also use my (don’t laugh) Nu-Wave oven which grills them perfectly. We like them really rare and this does a perfect job. Eva

Reply

Could you give us the temperatures you are using? “High” on my old Weber was about 400°F, I have since replaced that grill with a Weber Summit S-670, and when I set the sear section to high (other zones completely off for indirect purposes) the grill generally hovers between 650°F & 675°F when lid is closed.

Best,

-=mt

Reply

Moss,

For me, high means over 500. If I can hold my hand over the grill grates (an inch or so above them) and count to more than 2 before I can’t hold my hand there anymore, then it’s not hot enough…

…….Scott

I marinade chuck eye steaks with Lowery’s Sesame Ginger 30 minute marinade for about an hour at room temperature. Then high heat (@ 450-500) on the grill, 7 minutes one side, 5-6 flipped. Let sit covered a few minutes and on serving sprinkle with pepper, phenomenal. So tender and melts in your mouth. I would easily put this up against a ribeye with this prep and challenge someone to tell the difference. And shhhh! Keep this cut off meat a secret!

Reply

Sounds amazing, Theo. I need to try that!

…….Scott

A local butcher turned me onto these several years ago. I look almost every time I go shopping, but rarely see them. Great idea about the BOGO or BO G 1/2 price…….will keep that in mind. Used to be a lot cheaper, but like everything else, it’s gone up. My outdoor grill no longer works, but a quick pan fry and finished in the broiler or super hot oven would be good too :) Happy I found this site.

Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rate this recipe: